Archive for the Peggy Noonan Category

De-Bunked Theories on President Obama and Writers who are Past Their Day

Posted in Donald Trump, Peggy Noonan, President Barack Obama with tags , , on October 17, 2015 by Rich Wilkins

12002244_902350546505189_7321163874920211614_n

I’m always amused when I see Reagan era figures brought on television or into print as “expert pundits” in Washington. I mean, I get that they made it to the White House, so they deserve some respect, but it was a different era than today. Today’s GOP doesn’t agree with them on a lot of core issues. Today’s Democratic Party isn’t Tip O’Neill’s. National elections are a lot different than they were in the 1980s, in no small part because they are a lot less white. Things have changed a lot since they were in the White House.

So of course, I was amused by Peggy Noonan’s piece yesterday about Joe Biden and Donald Trump, mostly because it told me more about her view of President Obama. She nailed some of her analysis of the Democratic contest, but still bombed some parts of it. She bombed her analysis of the Trump candidacy. Then she wrote this:

The only thing I feel certain of is how we got here. There are many reasons we’re at this moment, but the essential political one is this: Mr. Obama lowered the bar. He was a literal unknown, an obscure former state legislator who hadn’t completed his single term as U.S. senator, but he was charismatic, canny, compelling. He came from nowhere and won it all twice. All previously prevailing standards, all usual expectations, were thrown out the window.

This is her explanation for how Donald Trump became an acceptable candidate. It’s wrong for several reasons:

  1. Yes, Barack Obama was young for a President, and perhaps had less lines on his resume than many others, but we haven’t been electing Lyndon Johnson for a while in America. From Jimmy Carter forward, the only two Presidents we’ve elected with experience in Congress were President Obama and President George H.W. Bush. President George W. Bush came into office with six years experience as Governor of Texas. President Reagan had only served as Governor of California and President Clinton as Governor and Attorney General of Arkansas. Yes, Senator Obama had served only a couple of terms in the Illinois Senate, and four years in the U.S. Senate, but he’s not really an outlier in that sense.
  2. The rise of Donald Trump has less to do with President Obama than it does with the waves of freshman Republicans in Congress in 2010 and 2014. The best way to explain this came to me from a Republican hack who told me that the difference between 2010 and 1994 was that the 1994 wave was a bunch of Mayors and State Legislators coming to Congress, and 2010 was a bunch of outsiders that were true-believers. In this group weren’t people with government resumes, which is driving why they are more confrontational and less interested in governing. They are the exact mold by which the Trump candidacy has grown from.

Noonan’s “Obama came out of nowhere” notion is not grounded in reality, but it’s widespread in DC. “But he doesn’t follow our norms here” is like the rallying cry of Washington since 2009, but it’s really just code for that he called BS on most of it. Yes, President Obama has introduced some radical concepts to people from the Reagan era- like talking to Cuba and Iran. This is less because he “came from nowhere,” and more because he rejected the tired Washington group-think that dictated foreign policy. Yes, President Obama basically rejected Reagan-era terms that dictated the economic debate, but this is less because he “came from nowhere” too, and more because he realized they were tired talking points that were really just code the status quo. None of this is because President Obama was inexperienced or unprepared, or any other Noonan-esque talking point, and more so because President Obama came to the Presidency as a response to the last thirty years of American politics that preceded him. He had as much or more experience before taking the job as most of his recent peers, in so much as that experience matters at all. No one is prepared to be President before they are.

This gets back to the whole idea though that these Reagan era pundits should have remained fixtures in our political media after 2008. They shouldn’t have. They offered little insight into a changing political world, a world where the Republican coalition of voters is increasingly militant, and the Democratic coalition is increasingly less white and male, and is younger. These pundits just don’t understand what they’re watching, partially because it’s so different than their experience, and partially because they just don’t want to try to. If you’re understanding Trump’s candidacy through President Obama, you are definitely doing it wrong.

Sincerely GC

Welcome To My Perfectly Imperfect World

Glam Meets Girl

Irish Based Fashion & Beauty Blog

Fantastic Em

{Daily life, cooking endeavors, & travel adventures galore}

28 and Counting...

Instructions for living a life: Pay attention. Be astonished. Tell about it. -Mary Oliver

MLB.com Blogs

Official Affiliate / Unofficial Opinions

TIME

Current & Breaking News | National & World Updates

tonysbologna : Honest. Satirical. Observations.

Honest. Satirical. Observations.

Ordinary Adventures

Everyday journeys of a one of a kind girl.

WJBF-TV

Coverage You Can Count On

The Cutter Rambles

The Cutter shares his thoughts on the world

dwiedy58

A great WordPress.com site

One Positive Blog

Don't worry and live a happy life

Online money

easy way to earn money

ELLIS NELSON BOOKS

young adult, middle grade, children's books

Mind the Gap

The socio-economic class divide in the UK

CBS New York

Breaking News, Sports, Weather, Traffic And The Best of NY

The Zo Zone

Inside the Phillies with MLB.com beat writer Todd Zolecki

Supernal Living with Dana Taylor

Supernal Living--Best-selling Amazon author Dana Taylor, exploring spirituality, healing energy, visionary writing, and wonder

Drinking Your Milkshake

Personal musings from a young designer.

Orange County for Darfur Blog

a project of Living Ubuntu

Where Love Abounds

From my heart to these pages

kottapallyragavi

The greatest WordPress.com site in all the land!

Words We Women Write

we do what we like and we like what we do

Polloplayer

a diary of my journey into chickendom. and other stuff.

teflresearch

Bringing language research into the classroom

For The Win

What fans are talking about.

The Seeds 4 Life

Seeds of Inspiration, Wisdom, and Positivity

CBS Philly

News, Sports, Weather, Traffic and Philly's Top Spots

Food Fellowship and Wine

A celebration of all things good

The Sober Sous Chef

Food, Family and Restaurant Life

Humanity777's Blog

The Church of Christ

mtaggartwriter

Read on, it's good for the brain.

Storyshucker

A blog full of humorous and poignant observations.

Political Fails

When politics, government and Social Media collide

FiveThirtyEight

Nate Silver’s FiveThirtyEight uses statistical analysis — hard numbers — to tell compelling stories about politics, sports, science, economics and culture.

Observer

People and Trends

JONATHAN TURLEY

Res ipsa loquitur ("The thing itself speaks")

Tsu Official Site

New Social Network Tsu — Which Pays Users Who Post — Raises $7 Million .

Phuture Phillies

Phillies Prospects

Life

in whispers

biovivoblog

Bio este viata